Compare Quotes
HomeCar Insurance ResourcesTop 10 most expensive cities to get car insurance in Ontario

Canada, is known for having some of the highest car insurance rates in the country, with certain cities standing out as particularly expensive. Here are a few of the most costly cities for car insurance in Ontario:

  1. Brampton:
    • Average Rate: Approximately CAD 2,800 per year.
    • Reason: Brampton has traditionally had high rates due to factors such as high traffic density, more frequent claims, and a higher number of reported cases of insurance fraud.
  2. Vaughan:
    • Average Rate: Approximately CAD 2,650 per year.
    • Reason: Vaughan, similar to Brampton, has had its rates influenced by higher traffic density, a significant number of claims, and instances of insurance fraud.
  3. Mississauga:
    • Average Rate: Approximately CAD 2,500 per year.
    • Reason: As one of the largest cities in Ontario and being adjacent to Toronto, it experiences a lot of the same challenges as Toronto such as heavy traffic, higher risk of collisions, and theft.
  4. Toronto:
    • Average Rate: Approximately CAD 2,400 per year.
    • Reason: As Canada’s largest city, Toronto has dense traffic, a high number of vehicles, and a greater probability of collisions. These factors combine to raise insurance rates.
  5. Markham:
    • Average Rate: Approximately CAD 2,350 per year.
    • Reason: Located near Toronto, Markham faces similar issues like high traffic density and a higher number of claims.
  1. Richmond Hill:
    • Average Rate: Approximately CAD 2,300 per year.
    • Reason: Located in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA), Richmond Hill experiences many of the same challenges as its neighboring cities. Traffic congestion, combined with a high population density, contributes to elevated risks of accidents and subsequently higher insurance premiums.
  2. Ajax:
    • Average Rate: Approximately CAD 2,200 per year.
    • Reason: Ajax, situated in the eastern part of the GTA, experiences high commuter traffic, especially with residents working in Toronto and other nearby cities. This increased daily vehicular activity results in higher insurance rates.
  3. Pickering:
    • Average Rate: Approximately CAD 2,150 per year.
    • Reason: Like Ajax, Pickering is affected by its proximity to Toronto and other populous cities in the GTA. With high commuter traffic and the associated risks, insurance rates tend to be higher.
  4. Oakville:
    • Average Rate: Approximately CAD 2,100 per year.
    • Reason: As a western suburb of Toronto, Oakville has a mix of residential and commercial zones. Its location along major highways like the QEW means higher traffic volumes, leading to a higher potential for accidents and claims.
  5. Milton:
  • Average Rate: Approximately CAD 2,050 per year.
  • Reason: Milton’s rapid growth and development in recent years have resulted in increased traffic and, subsequently, higher insurance premiums.

Factors Driving High Insurance Costs:

  • High Traffic Density: More vehicles on the road can lead to a higher risk of accidents.
  • Insurance Fraud: Instances of insurance fraud, like staged collisions, can drive up insurance premiums for everyone in the area.
  • Theft: Areas with a higher incidence of vehicle theft can see higher premiums.
  • Claim Frequency: If drivers in a certain area tend to make insurance claims more frequently than those in other areas, premiums can rise.
  • Demographics: The age distribution, especially if there’s a higher concentration of young drivers, can influence rates as younger drivers often face higher premiums.
  • Vehicle Type: The make and model of a car can significantly influence insurance rates. Sports cars or luxury vehicles typically have higher premiums due to repair costs and theft rates.
  • Coverage Level: The level of coverage a driver selects can also influence rates. Comprehensive coverage will be pricier than basic third-party liability.
  • Deductible Amount: A higher deductible often means a lower annual premium, but it also means the driver will pay more out-of-pocket in the event of a claim.
  • Driver’s Record: A driver’s history, including any at-fault accidents or traffic violations, will directly impact their insurance premiums.
  • Usage: How a car is used, whether for commuting daily or occasional leisurely drives, will play a role in determining rates.

How can I lower my auto insurance premiums?


  1. Shop Around: This is one of the most effective ways to get a better rate. Insurance rates can vary widely between companies for the same coverage. Periodically get quotes from multiple insurance providers to ensure you’re getting the best deal.
  2. Bundle Your Insurance: If you have other types of insurance, such as home or life insurance, consider bundling them with the same provider. Many companies offer discounts for multiple policies.
  3. Increase Your Deductible: Agreeing to a higher deductible can lower your premiums. However, ensure you can afford the deductible in the event of a claim.
  4. Take Advantage of Discounts:
    • Multi-vehicle discount: If you insure more than one vehicle.
    • Good driver discount: For those with no claims or convictions for a certain period.
    • Student discounts: For young drivers with good academic performance.
    • Retiree discount: Some companies offer discounts for retirees.
    • Winter tire discount: For installing winter tires during the colder months.
  5. Drive Less: Some companies offer reduced rates for drivers who have a lower annual mileage. If possible, consider carpooling, using public transport, or telecommuting.
  6. Maintain a Clean Driving Record: Avoiding accidents and traffic violations will typically result in lower premiums.
  7. Choose Your Vehicle Wisely: The type of car you drive affects your insurance rates. Vehicles that are less expensive to repair or have good safety ratings can be cheaper to insure.
  8. Take a Defensive Driving Course: Some insurance providers offer discounts to drivers who’ve completed approved defensive driving or driver’s education courses.
  9. Review Coverage on Older Vehicles: If you have an older vehicle, consider if you need comprehensive or collision coverage. Sometimes the cost of these coverages exceeds the vehicle’s value.
  10. Install Safety and Anti-theft Devices: Installing approved anti-theft devices and safety features can sometimes earn you a discount.
  11. Group Discounts: Some providers offer discounts if you’re a member of certain organizations, alumni groups, or professional associations.
  12. Pay Annually: Paying your premium in a lump sum annually, instead of monthly, can sometimes reduce the overall cost.
  13. Review Your Policy Regularly: As your life changes (e.g., moving, changing jobs, adding drivers), ensure your policy reflects your current situation and adjust accordingly.
  14. Consider Usage-Based Insurance: Some insurers offer policies where premiums are based on how you drive, monitored by a telematics device installed in your vehicle. Safe and infrequent drivers can benefit from lower rates.
  15. Ask About Loyalty Discounts: If you’ve been with an insurer for several years, see if they offer discounts for long-term customers.

About the Author: Valerie D. Hahn

Valerie is an insurance editor, journalist, and business professional at RateLab. She has more than 15 years of experience in personal financial products. She strives to educate readers and ensure that they are properly protected.

Leave A Comment

Continue Reading