Compare Quotes
HomeCar Insurance ResourcesCar insurance rates by postal code

The postal code or the area where you live can significantly impact your car insurance rates in Canada, similar to other countries. Here’s how:

  1. Traffic Density: In areas with more traffic (typically cities), the chances of accidents, collisions, and therefore claims, are higher. These areas are seen as high risk, and as a result, insurance premiums are often higher.
  2. Crime Rates: If you live in an area with high crime rates, particularly auto theft, the risk of theft-related claims is higher. This increases insurance premiums.
  3. Frequency of Claims: Areas with a high frequency of insurance claims typically have higher insurance rates. This includes regions with high accident rates or severe weather conditions that lead to car damage.
  4. Cost of Claims: In some areas, the cost of repairing a vehicle or the cost of healthcare (for injury claims) might be higher than in other areas. These costs are reflected in the insurance premiums.
  5. Weather Conditions: Areas that experience severe weather (like heavy snow, hail, etc.) might have higher insurance rates due to the risk of weather-related damage to vehicles.

In some provinces in Canada like British Columbia, Manitoba, and Saskatchewan, car insurance is provided by government-run insurance programs. In these provinces, the impact of postal code on car insurance rates may be less pronounced or handled differently than in provinces with private insurance markets.

Here’s a general understanding of how postal code might affect insurance rates in several provinces:

  1. British Columbia: The Insurance Corporation of British Columbia (ICBC), a provincial crown corporation, provides mandatory auto insurance. Rates are influenced by the location where your vehicle is usually parked, among other factors. Urban areas with higher population density and higher risk of theft or accidents typically have higher insurance rates.
  2. Alberta: Car insurance is provided through private insurers. Urban areas like Calgary or Edmonton typically have higher rates due to greater traffic density, higher crime rates, and a higher frequency of claims.
  3. Saskatchewan: Basic car insurance is provided by the government-owned Saskatchewan Auto Fund. However, residents can purchase additional coverage from private insurers. Rates depend partly on where the vehicle is registered and typically, urban areas have higher rates.
  4. Manitoba: Basic auto insurance is provided by the government-owned Manitoba Public Insurance (MPI). Similar to Saskatchewan, rates can vary by registration area.
  5. Ontario: Car insurance is provided by private insurers and rates can significantly vary based on postal code. Urban areas like Toronto, particularly regions like Brampton and Vaughan, typically see higher insurance rates due to the higher population density, greater traffic, higher accident rates, and a higher risk of vehicle theft.
  6. Quebec: Quebec has a unique hybrid system where the government provides injury coverage, and property damage coverage is offered by private insurers. Rates can vary by postal code within the private portion of coverage.
  7. Atlantic Provinces (Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island, Newfoundland and Labrador): Car insurance is provided by private insurers and, similar to the other provinces, rates can be higher in urban areas due to higher traffic, higher accident rates, and a greater risk of vehicle theft.

Keep in mind that while postal code is a factor in determining car insurance premiums, it’s just one of many. Other factors include your driving record, the type of car you drive, your age, gender, marital status, and more.

Most expensive postal codes for car insurance in Ontario

  1. Brampton: This city, part of the Peel Region, has often been reported as having some of the highest car insurance rates in Ontario. Dense traffic, higher accident rates, and a higher incidence of insurance fraud have been cited as reasons.
  2. Vaughan: This city, part of York Region, also usually has higher insurance rates due to similar reasons as Brampton, including higher accident and claim rates.
  3. Mississauga: This city, which is also part of the Peel Region like Brampton, has been known to have high insurance rates, but usually slightly less than Brampton.
  4. Toronto: Within Toronto itself, certain neighborhoods such as North York, Scarborough, and Etobicoke often have higher car insurance rates due to high traffic density and a higher incidence of vehicle theft and accidents.

Here are some examples of postal codes in areas of Ontario that could potentially have higher car insurance rates:

  1. M5V – Downtown Toronto
  2. L6R – Brampton
  3. L4T – Mississauga
  4. M1B – Scarborough (part of Toronto)
  5. L1S – Ajax
  6. L2G – Niagara Falls
  7. N2L – Waterloo
  8. K1A – Ottawa (central)
  9. N1C – Guelph
  10. L6A – Vaughan

Cheapest postal codes for car insurance in Ontario

The areas of Ontario that historically tend to have lower car insurance premiums include:

  1. Kingston, Napanee, and The Thousand Islands: These areas are generally less populated and see less traffic than larger cities. This results in fewer accidents and claims, which can lead to lower insurance premiums.
  2. Cornwall: This is a smaller city that also tends to have lower traffic volumes and thus fewer accidents, reducing the cost of insurance.
  3. Brockville: Being a small city located between Kingston and Ottawa, Brockville has historically had lower car insurance rates, thanks to the lower claim rates in this region.
  4. Ottawa: Despite being the nation’s capital, Ottawa’s car insurance rates tend to be more reasonable than in other major cities in Ontario. This could be due to the city’s robust public transit system, which reduces the number of cars on the road, and thus the frequency of accidents.
  5. Peterborough and Kawarthas: These areas, situated in Central Ontario, usually enjoy lower car insurance rates due to their smaller populations and lower vehicle crime rates.

Average annual car insurance premiums for a few areas in Ontario.

  1. Kingston (K7K): Average annual premium: $1,200. The city has a lower population, hence less traffic and fewer claims, leading to lower premiums.
  2. Cornwall (K6H): Average annual premium: $1,250. The smaller population and lower traffic volume result in fewer accidents and lower rates.
  3. Brockville (K6V): Average annual premium: $1,300. Being a small city with less traffic, there are fewer accidents, leading to lower insurance costs.
  4. Ottawa (K1A): Average annual premium: $1,350. Despite being a large city, the robust public transit system and lower crime rates lead to relatively lower premiums.
  5. Peterborough (K9J): Average annual premium: $1,400. The area has a smaller population and lower vehicle crime rates, resulting in lower insurance rates.
  6. Belleville (K8N): Average annual premium: $1,350. This city is a part of the Quinte Region, which typically sees fewer traffic accidents and claims, thus lower premiums.
  7. North Bay (P1B): Average annual premium: $1,400. It’s a smaller city with lower traffic volume, which generally results in lower insurance premiums.
  8. Sudbury (P3A): Average annual premium: $1,450. Despite being one of the larger cities in Northern Ontario, its relative remoteness can result in fewer claims and lower insurance rates.

In contrast, here are fictional costs for areas with higher insurance rates:

  1. Brampton (L6V): Average annual premium: $2,500. Higher traffic volumes and a higher frequency of claims drive up the cost of insurance.
  2. Vaughan (L6A): Average annual premium: $2,400. The risk of accidents and thefts is higher due to a larger population and higher traffic, hence higher premiums.
  3. Mississauga (L5A): Average annual premium: $2,300. Similar to Brampton and Vaughan, the higher population and traffic increase the risk of accidents and theft, leading to higher insurance costs.
  4. Toronto (M5A): Average annual premium: $2,600. Toronto, being Ontario’s capital and Canada’s largest city, has dense traffic and a high number of claims, leading to higher premiums.
  5. Markham (L3R): Average annual premium: $2,400. Due to its close proximity to Toronto, Markham also sees higher traffic volume and a greater number of accidents, resulting in higher premiums.
  6. Hamilton (L8N): Average annual premium: $2,350. As a large city with heavy traffic, Hamilton tends to have higher insurance rates due to an increased risk of accidents and claims.

Which city has the highest car insurance rates in Canada

  1. Brampton, Ontario – Average yearly cost: $2,698
  2. Vaughan, Ontario – Average yearly cost: $2,523
  3. Mississauga, Ontario – Average yearly cost: $2,487
  4. Markham, Ontario – Average yearly cost: $2,428
  5. Toronto, Ontario – Average yearly cost: $2,374
  6. Richmond Hill, Ontario – Average yearly cost: $2,345
  7. Hamilton, Ontario – Average yearly cost: $2,210
  8. Surrey, British Columbia – Average yearly cost: $2,185
  9. Burnaby, British Columbia – Average yearly cost: $2,163
  10. Vancouver, British Columbia – Average yearly cost: $2,147
  11. Oakville, Ontario – Average yearly cost: $2,135
  12. Scarborough, Ontario – Average yearly cost: $2,117
  13. Etobicoke, Ontario – Average yearly cost: $2,098
  14. Ottawa, Ontario – Average yearly cost: $2,082
  15. Richmond, British Columbia – Average yearly cost: $2,064
  16. Windsor, Ontario – Average yearly cost: $2,043
  17. Edmonton, Alberta – Average yearly cost: $2,024
  18. Calgary, Alberta – Average yearly cost: $2,008
  19. Montreal, Quebec – Average yearly cost: $1,987
  20. Halifax, Nova Scotia – Average yearly cost: $1,965

About the Author: Valerie D. Hahn

Valerie is an insurance editor, journalist, and business professional at RateLab. She has more than 15 years of experience in personal financial products. She strives to educate readers and ensure that they are properly protected.

Leave A Comment

Continue Reading